China After the Earthquake: Fascism, Spin, Gullibility and Blame

Chinese earthquake victims' funeral urns

Well, that didn’t take long, did it?

In the wake of the newest reports setting the death toll from the Chinese earthquake north of 50,000, the government response of 50,000 troops, which was initially hailed as a superb example of the actions of a government in complete control of its situation, is looking a little less adequite.

It takes two soldiers to carry one body.

May 14, The Guardian:

Authorities coping with disaster without need for outside help

Duncan Campbell

Initial indications are that the Chinese feel they have sufficient resources and experience to deal with the earthquake’s aftermath, although aid organisations and foreign governments have offered help, both financially and in terms of expertise…

Among international agencies and governments, the general feeling that seems to be emerging is that China has the infrastructure, the personnel, the resources and the experience to deal with the crisis without significant outside help. Whereas it was immediately clear that Burma would not be able to cope with the scale of their disaster on their own, China, with its vast army and its previous knowledge of severe earthquakes, presented a very different picture.

May 17th, The Guardian:

Beijing open to foreign aid and scrutiny in wake of tragedy

Julian Borger

For the first time, Beijing has accepted aid from abroad and invited rescue teams from Japan, Russia, South Korea, Singapore and even Taiwanese charities. US offers of direct assistance were declined but China’s embassy in Washington encouraged Americans to send cash and supplies, a distinct break with the past.

May 21st, The Guardian:

China dissident held ‘for criticising quake response

Jonathan Watts

Chinese police have detained a political dissident because of remarks he made about the government’s handling of the Sichuan earthquake, according to his family and supporters.

Guo Quan, the founder of the China Democracy party, was seized outside his home by seven or eight police officers four days ago. They searched his house and confiscated his computer.

“They waited outside and caught him as he was taking our child to school,” said his wife Li Jing…

In the past week, he is said to have raised questions about the emergency services’ response to the quake and the safety of nuclear facilities in Sichuan. Fellow members of his small party believe his detention is connected to last week’s disaster.

Well then, I think we can all understand why Duncan Campbell was being so boosterish, can’t we? That must be pretty strong Kool-Aid they have in China, I’m thinking, except that … Duncan Campbell is actually in the UK and Jonathan Watts is in Beijing.

add to del.icio.us : Add to Blinkslist : add to furl : Digg it : add to ma.gnolia : Stumble It! : add to simpy : seed the vine : : : TailRank : post to facebook

18 thoughts on “China After the Earthquake: Fascism, Spin, Gullibility and Blame

  1. In a country whose leadership tries to forget the Cultural Revolution and drags out the Japanese slaughter of hundreds of thousands of Chinese civilians in the 30’s and World War Two only when it’s politically expedient, what do you expect? It’s a wholly different institutional outlook on the value of human life.

  2. His ding-dongs were mostly made at Andover and Yale.

    As to Campbell, why on earth is he so down on Burma when they appear to be coping more or less equally well?

  3. Huh? Who pays attention to what Campbell says anymore? We’re stuck with him till someone poisons him, like an old dog that’s no good. But he has all the global relevance of an old hound dog.

  4. Pingback: 100 Blog Posts About China Earthquake

  5. Rainy…rainy, where else i could get corny? (Lmfao at FFE and your fancily defensive replies, too)

    Anyway, […] It takes two soldier to carry one body […]. To me, it’s not more than showing off China’s supremacy on men producing. No wonder they managed to be the most powerful country — in term of inhabitant numbers ! May be there should be a global road sign here in Indonesia saying ‘NO MORE SPACE FOR CHINESE RACE’. Oops…, do i sound racist? Nope, i’m just trying to give chinese a credit :-D.

    P.S. Don’t bother to take the joke, only javanese understand this kind of joke.
    Regards [spam link deleted by raincoaster, and for good measure the one on his name, too, just because he’s an ass. You can see the forums at http://en.forums.wordpress.com for details]

  6. Your spam link has been deleted. You’re already banned at several places around WordPress…do you want to be banned here, too?

    Yes, you sound racist. And you very obviously don’t understand what anyone here is talking about.

Leave a comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.