picture this: photojournalism and fairness in the War in Lebanon

Fair and balanced? 

Here’s an interesting articticle from the New York Times about how the American media is dealing with the challenge of showing the war. Traditionally, media have displayed images from one side of the conflict against images from the opposite side, striving for that journalistic impartiality that everyone worships except Hunter Thompson, and look what happened to him.

But is that really fair or objective, when one sides casualties outnumber the others’ by a factor of ten? What is objective coverage in that case? Ten photos of dead Lebanese for every one of a dead Israeli? And of course, Hezbollah has fired more on Israel than Israel has on Lebanon, although with less effect. So do you show ten times the tracers going south as going north?

What is objective journalism when the facts themselves can be interpreted as prejudicial?

Particularly vexing for many American news organizations is the struggle to determine how and in what proportion images of civilian dead and injured should be displayed in their coverage, when one side’s casualties greatly surpass the other.

The journalistic calculus is made tougher by the involvement of the Arab-Israeli conflict, a topic that bedevils news editors like no other, and an organization, Hezbollah, that is considered a terrorist group by the United States government. But the decision-making becomes even more fraught because of the power of photographs and TV images, which are evocative — and provocative — in ways the written and spoken word are not.

Hunting Dogs

from the Archive

Let me tell you about the time me and Harley the dog were down at the park at midnight.

It’s dark then. Sometimes this is good, sometimes this is bad. Depends what you’re up to. For us it was good and bad. We were there to poo and get sleepy. Well, Harley was, but he didn’t know it. He thought he was there to party. But then, he’s only four years old, what does he know about hidden agendas? I had one, and now you know about it; he still doesn’t, because as far as I know he cannot read.

We entered the park on the eastern walkway, a wide sidewalk that gradually climbs the slope between two rows of tall flowering bushes. At the top it opened into the park itself, an oasis of dogwoods, waterfalls, perfect green lawns, and reflecting pools covered with a snowfall of pink cherry blossoms. I looked up at the moonless, cloudless sky, empty all the way to Arcturis, and I let Harley off the leash.

He knew the score. He began barking frantically, bouncing up and down on his front legs and throwing his head from side to side.

I moved higher up the slope, near the waterfall pools where the junkies wash their clothes. Sometimes the pools look like bubblebaths, especially if the boosters have scored some soap from the Army and Navy Department Store. The power of the water falling four or five feet pounds out a lot of the dirt without scrubbing, so the junkies can pass out on the grass secure in the knowledge that their jeans will be cleaned automatically, if they aren’t stolen. At night the park is too busy for that, and so are the junkies. The hookers take their clients here, and there are deals to be made on the benches, lots of deals. At the very top of the slope is a metal daisy with a thick stem, short pipes of steel coming off it like branches; these pipes are open at the end, and a sign says “Keep our park clean. Deposit used rigs here.” Nice.

So that’s where I was, not too near any bushes or benches, as I wished not to interfere with any commerce that might be taking place there. People are very sensitive about their commerce, and take it unkindly if you occupy their place of business. And if you look too respectable you will scare off the customers and that gets back to the sensitive about commerce angle I was mentioning. So I was nowhere near no thing, and Harley was hopping along in my wake, wagging his tail and barking because he’s just a dog, and they do that.

I reach in the bag. Harley goes wild and whips around, galloping downhill with his tongue hanging out. And I throw the ball.

I always like the first throw of the night. It’s clean, fresh, all those nice-sounding things they say in tampon commercials, even unscented. After that it gets covered in a progressively thicker and more repulsive layer of slime that has the single benefit of making it impossible for goose shit to stick to the ball. Harley’s slobber makes it impossible for anything to stick to anything, except the slime, which sticks to everything; I’m sure NATO could use it for some very advanced weapon system of some kind.
The ball goes high and long; this is the advantage of throwing from the top of a hill. You throw only so far, but the earth itself falls away from the throw, so Harley covers twice the distance of the toss. Then he has to turn around and go uphill, which poops him out even more. I have this down to a system; it’s like fortified cereal, but for exercise.


One of my favorite things about this little park, Andy Livingstone Park, is that the ball invariably lands in a well-lit area, there being streetlights all along the fire lane at the bottom of the hill. This is good, so Harley can find the ball; it is also good so I can see Harley is finding the ball, rather than checking out a skunk or sniffing butts with a coyote or taking off after a rat or a bag from McDonalds. Or licking up puke, he’s big on licking up puke. I figure if a junkie couldn’t keep it down it sure can’t be good for him, so I discourage this practice most strongly, which is hard, especially on That Very Special Wednesday as there is a great deal of puke just lying around, looking tempting. Very difficult to play fetch and discourage puke-slurping at the same time, but it can be done.

I see Harley get the ball. Fetch, Harley, fetch. Come, Harley, come. Oh, fine, ignore me. You think you’re so smart wandering around with your nose in the air and a big red IndesctructaBall in your mouth. Hey, get out of there! I hear much bush-crashing. He’s not what anyone would call a dainty dog. I hear a couple of voices, who don’t sound friendly, but if I can’t see them I figure they can’t see me and if they can’t then they can’t do too much to me, now can they? But where’s the dog? Ah, there he is, at the other end of the bushes, having rooted through a junkie’s McStash. He still has ketchup on his chin, and an innocent expression on his face.

And no ball.

Spiffy, he dropped it in the bushes. I think about the hooker and client and decide they have probably left by now, so it should be as safe as wandering around in dark, rat-infested bushes where junkies drop their needles ever gets. So I begin to wander around in the dark, rat-infested bushes where the junkies drop their needles. Silently, I begin composing a thank-you letter to the people who made my hiking boots with such nice, thick soles. I’m glad I have ski gloves, though the Canadarm would come in handy, too.

As I’m rooting around in the prickly darkness, I hear a voice.

“Ya need any help in there? That’s not such a good idea fer a young lady like you to be doing.”

“No kidding, but my dog dropped his ball and it cost me ten bucks.” I sound much tougher than him, and am momentarily embarrassed. I look out and see that the speaker is a slim, middle-aged man with a ballcap and a grey ‘stache. He has the Downtown EastSide look, which is like Keith Richards without the money and the eyeliner. Probably a dealer. He does not look like he is into causing me trouble.

“I’ll help you look,” he says. “Things are kind of slow right now.” and he does, he helps me for a half hour or more. We chat. I learn all about how when he was young his family raised show dogs, about his preference for the working breeds, about his belief that humanity’s low avarice has ruined once-great animals like the collie and the labrador. He hears me out about pugs and says if that’s what they’re really like then he just might change his mind about them, I mean, if they’re really like that. I hear about his cross-country odyssey, and how he loves prairie river valleys. Prettiest places on earth. I hear about his military service; we try to figure out if he crossed paths with my dad and decide he did not.

Then, after half an hour of teamwork, Harley comes up to us with the ball in his mouth. Dumb dog.

There are people waiting by the bench. The guy says, “Well, nice chatting with ya, but I’d better go.”

“Yes,” I say, “Don’t want to keep you from business. Thanks.”

I put Harley back on the leash, the fellow pets him a few times and tells him what a fine, handsome fellow he is, and Harley and I go home. The man stays behind, dealing.

review o’ the day: Geoffrey Chaucer on video games

Gower, take thatte!G-Chaus is back, with a roundup of the hottest video games on the market.

From TYGER WOODSES HUNTINGE AND HAWKINGE to GRANDE THEFTE, COLLUSIOUN, AND MAYNTENANCE, he gives his loyale readeres the hot poop on slick tech products that we’ve come to expect of the fourteenth century’s most prolific blogger.

Bonus points for using the Latinate “Margaritae“.

O my gentil rederes, it hath been a thinge of muche difficultee and laboure for to type euen the smallest entrie in myn blogge. For somer, lyk vnto a songe of Barry Manilow, hath ydrawn alle the spirit and vigor from my limbes and hert. For the gretre part of the hot moneth of July ich laye in my garden on my comfortable lawn-chaire and langwisshed lyk vnto sum yonge lover who hath ydumpede been. Ich daubede myn foreheed wyth a moyste towel and did drinke mvch of somer drinkes swich as margaritae and daquiri…
 

And so, my noble rederes, vntil the hete of somer fullie abateth, ich shal be up wyth litel Lowys, in hys attic room, playinge of video games and drinkinge depe draughtes of mountayne dewe. C U L8re, gentilz!

Ich Pwne Noobs

British terror suspects named

Fuck Censorship!The Guardian reports that pressure has been brought to bear on the media by the Metropolitan Police, the Home Secretary and the Attorney General of the UK to prevent media coverage of the suspects, amid fears that such coverage may prejudice a trail.

Of course, this begs the question of how fair can it be show greater respect for privacy of these particular suspects than any regular old suspects, who could and would be named with impunity. If the system is so irrevocably broken that merely stating “Mr. So-and-So has been arrested” will prejudice the trial, how then can it be fair to name other suspects in other crimes?

Let justice be blind; either outlaw the release of names or allow it. Interference by the judiciary, the legislature, or law enforcement in the dissemination of information is arbitrary and truly prejudicial. Does this interference mean that all other trials in Britain are unjust, and we’re okay with that?

The suspects:

The names on the Bank of England website are:

Walthamstow, London E17

Muhammed Usman Saddique, 24, lives in Albert Road. Attends Queens Road mosque

Waheed Zaman, 22, head of Islamic Society at London Metropolitan University

Assan Abdullah Khan, 21, lives in Banbury Road with brother and fellow suspect Abdula Ahmed Ali

Waheed Arafat Khan, 25, lives in Farnan Avenue

Cossor Ali, 23

Osman Adam Khatib, 19, lives in Wellington Road

Amin Asmin Tariq, 23, security guard at Heathrow

Abdula Ahmed Ali, 25, lives in Banbury Road with brother and fellow suspect Assan Abdullah Khan

Ibrahim Savant, 25, lives in Alkam Road. Changed name from Oliver Savant when converted to Islam. Attends Queens Road mosque

Poplar, London E14

Umair Hussain, 24

Stoke Newington, London

Shamin Mohammed Uddin, 35, oldest of the known suspects

Chingford, Essex

Nabeel Hussain, 22

Leyton, London E10

Tanvir Hussain, 25

Clapton, London E5

Abdul Muneem Patel, 17, youngest known suspect

High Wycombe, Buckinghamshire

Waseem Kayani, 29, reported to have recently returned from Pakistan, where he married

Umar Islam, 28, West Indian Christian background; changed name from Brian Young when converted to Islam

Assad Sarwar, 26, believed to have attended the Muslim Education Centre in Totteridge Drive. Brother of suspect Amjad Sarwar

Shazad Khuram Ali, 27, believed to have attended the Muslim Education Centre in Totteridge Drive. Runs car import business, AKZ Trading. Brother of suspect Haider Ali

Birmingham

Tayib Rauf, 22, lives in Ward End. Works with brother at father’s cake business, Classic Confectionery Supplies. Brother, Rashid, arrested in Pakistan

Not on the Bank of England list:

Walthamstow

Atika Sidyot, wife of Ibrahim Savant. Reportedly pregnant

High Wycombe

Amjad Sarwar, 28, works at Shazad Khuram Ali’s car business, AKZ. Brother of Assad Sarwar UPDATE not arrested, not questioned. The Bank of England apparently released as “arrested” the name of a man who wasn’t even interviewed.

Adbul Waheed (or Wahid), 21, changed name from Don Stewart-Whyte when converted to Islam

Haider Ali, works for his brother Shazad Khuram Ali’s car business, AKZ

Unnamed, woman in her twenties with a six-month-old child

5???

I am obviously out of the dirty word waiting to happen loop here. Valleywag‘s published a list of 83 words you can’t communicate on Verizon Wireless, and sure enough most of them are pretty obvious: fuck, dago, spic, spankthemonkey (although it doesn’t rule out spank the monkey of course) and so on.

But 5???

I’m obviously missing something. Got to get out more.

the real reason I’m publishing this list is the more creative entries: “fleshpopsicle,” “spearchucker,” and “whiteswallow” (which I thought was one of the birds Craig Newmark feeds in his backyard). Like an 11-year-old boy, we had not thought of saying these words until we heard them, but now those words taste so good in our mouths.

Use the phrase “flesh popsicle” in a sentence today.

Disclosure: As far as I can tell, certain (but not all) entries from Gawker Media blogs are republished through Verizon and thus fall under these guidelines.

———- Forwarded message ———-

No Content provided to Subscribers of Verizon Wireless from Content Providers, whether in the form of text, audio, images, video or otherwise, may contain any of the words listed in Appendix A. This includes any variations in spelling of the words (e.g., fuck, phuck, fucks, fucker, fucked, fucking, etc.), any variations in pronunciation of the words (e.g., nigger, nigga, niggahs, etc.) or any combinations or creations containing any of the words (e.g., ass, assboy, asslicker, uptheass, etc.).

Nonetheless, it is not possible to compile a definitive list of unacceptable words. Language is fluid, with new words and phrases regularly entering the public vocabulary, and established meanings may change over time. For this reason, the list of prohibited words in Appendix A may change from time to time and is not meant to be all-inclusive.

anal
ass
bastard
beatoff
bitch
BJ
cameljockey
chink
circlejerk
clit
cock
coolie
coon
cornhole
cum
cunt
dago
deepthroating
dickhead
dickwad
dildo
dyke
eatme
fag
faggot
fellatio
fisting
fleshflute
fleshpopsicle
fornicate
fuck
fudgepacking
gangbang
genital
getlaid
gobtheknob
goldenshower
gook
hairpie
hardon
homo
honkey
jerkoff
jewboy
jizz
5
kike
lesbo
limey
manloaf
masturbate
muffdiver
nigger
nutsack
paki
panface
poontang
pubic
pussy
queef
queer
raghead
rimjob
rubyredbag
scrotum
shit
sitonmyface
sixtynine
slag
slant
sodomize
spankthemonkey
spearchucker
spic
spooge
teabagging
testicles
twat
vagina
wetback
whackoff
whipitout
whiteswallow
wop